259 Van Tuyl Road, Barryville NY

For Sale: $449,999

Interested? Call (845) 707-5274, email us, or use our form

A unique opportunity to own one of the most beautiful homes in Sullivan County. Built in 1893, Hillside Schoolhouse has a storied history -- first as a one-room schoolhouse, then Gospel Chapel, then, following a painstaking renovation in 2013, a boutique inn recognized as one of the Top 25 Hotels in the US by Conde Nast Traveler. Now offered as a stunning residence perfect as a full-time or second home, with a strong rental history for potential Airbnb or rental income. Character abounds throughout as the recent renovation preserved the original hardwoods, clapboard, slate chalkboards, and soaring 18-ft ceilings in the awe-inspiring 1400 square foot main living area. The renovation also added a custom staircase and 2nd floor with two en-suite bedrooms -- one of which sits directly below the original bell tower with its cast iron bell. The property also features a new roof, skylights, kitchen, half-bath, plumbing, furnace, central air, and septic system. Only 90 miles from NYC, Hillside Schoolhouse sits on a quiet mountain road 2 miles from the Delaware River.

General Information:

MLS#: 46993

Bedrooms: 2 beds

Bathrooms: 2 full, 1 half

Sq ft: 2,500

Lot: 1 acres

Year Built: 1893

Type: Single Family

Condition: Very Good

Possession Date:

Down Payment:
Map this property
The Sullivan Buzz - The Lowdown on a Town

5 Rooms - Interior Information

Cathedral Ceiling, Central Hall/Foyer, Family Room, Great Room, Hardwood Floors, Skylights, TV Cable, Woodwork

Square Feet Above Grade: 2,500

Square Feet Below Grade: 00

Full Baths: 2

Half Baths: 1


Basement: Crawl

Fireplaces: 0

Appliances: Refrigerator, Self Cleaning Oven

Fuel: Fuel Tank Above Ground, Oil

Electric: Circuit Breaker

Water: Drilled Well

Sewer: Septic

Heating: Forced Warm Air

Water Heater: Oil

Exterior information

Style: Colonial, Cottage, Custom

Siding: Clapboard, Wood

Roof: Pitched, Shingle


Acres: 1

Pool: No

Garage: -1 Car - Other

Land Features: Cleared, Level, Mature Trees

Land Condition:

Land Use Restrictions:

Road: County

Near (within 5 miles): Hotels, Lake/Stream, Parks, River, Schools, State Land

Common Facilities:


Tax and Fee Information

Bldg Assessment: $00

Land Assessment: -$01

Total Assessment: -$01

Tax Amount: $6,742

Tax Exemption? N

Present Usage:

Maintenance Fees:


Homeowner's Fees: -$01

Financing Terms:

Possible Financing: Conventional

Options: Sale

259 Van Tuyl Road
Barryville, NY 12719
EldredCent School District

Contact Our Agent

Charles Petersheim
Listing courtesy of Lazy Meadows Realty
©2017 Sullivan County Multiple Listing Service (SCMLS). The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes from Multiple Listing Service of The Sullivan County Board of Realtors and the Broker Reciprocity Program. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Lazy Meadows Realty, Inc. includes the name of the listing brokers. Listing broker has attempted to offer accurate data, but buyers are advised to confirm all items. Information last updated on 10/23/2017.